Compulsion Training for the Weak

“Weak mind, weak fist; strong mind, no need for fist” –Shaolin saying

Pinch collars are one form of compulsion training

Uh-oh, dog trainers who promote shock and pinch collars, use of punishment, theories of dominance, or any other kind of compulsion training method.

I’m not suggesting you’re weak-minded.

Martial arts experts from ancient times through today are.

And not just martial artists. Because Shaolin is actually from the Chinese Buddhism family – quite similar to Zen Buddhism from Japan. Even by Buddhist standards, you could use more mental tenacity.

Next time you want to recommend compulsion training methods for your canine clients, think about what that says about you. Or if you’ve contacted a trainer for help and they promote any of these methods. How much mental strength do you think they have? That is to say, how much creativity, patience, empathy, compassion, observation ability, and so on … all of the things you want from someone working with your special furry friend.

Only a weak mind resorts to using the fist—or, more broadly, physical force. Strong mind, no need for physical force.

Believe me, I know how easy it is to resort to harsh tactics when dealing with a stubborn dog. I haven’t always followed this sage advice, and with horrible consequences for my pit bull, Roxy.

So, how do we – not just trainers, but everyone – develop a strong mind so we don’t need to fall back on physical force or compulsion training?

Learning to perform with calmness under pressure is the whole point to meditation, yoga, martial arts – the whole point to life, in my opinion. Definitely, it’s the key to working with a dog exhibiting troubling behavior.

How we learn to do this totally depends on our personal preference. But the onus is on us to figure it out. Perhaps our troubled pets are here to help. Compulsion training methods rob us all of the chance to find out.



About Christie Green

I'm a certified health coach, intuitive healer, writer, animal-lover, and peace artist (formerly martial artist) helping clients create lives with more balance, less bark.
This entry was posted in A Mindful Life with Dogs and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Compulsion Training for the Weak

  1. “But the onus is on us to figure it out. ” Great post. For all our pride in our big brains we certainly like to be lazy when it comes to using them.

    • Haha, thanks, Lara! Actually, it’s more like we’re lazy in how we decide to use our brains. We’re so focused on achieving the goal, we forget the process matters even more, and we take shortcuts. I’m just as guilty (though, hopefully, not often). The best any of us can do is learn how to be mindful enough to recognize when we’re about to give up and then make a choice to continue doing what’s right. Not easy, but so worth it.

What Do You Think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s